- GoLetter Insider
- Posts
- Your newsletter isn’t tiny—it’s under-monetized
Your newsletter isn’t tiny—it’s under-monetized
Let’s fix your revenue engine before you chase CPMs.
Hey Newsletter Operators , it’s Mo!
In today’s issue:
Stop selling impressions. Sell outcomes.
The 20-second post-signup flow that prints CPL revenue
What to charge (real ranges) + quick math to stay honest
Templates you can paste today
Let’s get into it 👇
You don’t have a content problem.
You don’t have an audience size problem.
You have a monetization timing problem.
Most creators try to make revenue inside the email.
We make it differently.
How?
Add a 20-second step after “Subscribe.” Ask 2 smart questions, show one perfectly matched offer, collect brand-named consent, and deliver that hand-raise as a qualified lead (or booked consult) to a partner. Get paid per outcome (CPL/CPL-Booked). Use that cash to fund growth now.
Doesn’t make sense? let’s break it down.
1) What the flow looks like (end to end)
Subscribe → 20-sec micro-form → single offer screen → route lead → welcome email.
Subscribe page: one promise, one button. (“One useful email a week. No fluff.”)
Micro-form (2–3 Qs): routes the person to the right offer.
Offer screen (one partner only): short pitch + CTA + brand-named consent.
Routing: send the lead to the partner instantly; log everything your side.
Welcome email: deliver your promise + remind them what they opted into.
2) The exact 2–3 questions (copy/paste)
Pick your niche below and steal the set.
Newsletter for homeowners:
What do you need help with right now?
▢ Power washing ▢ Pest control ▢ Lawn care ▢ Home valuationZIP code: ______
Timing: ▢ This week ▢ 2–4 weeks ▢ Just browsing
Parenting Newsletter:
Baby’s age (or due date): ▢ Pregnant ▢ 0–3m ▢ 4–6m ▢ 7–12m
Help right now: ▢ Sleep ▢ Lactation ▢ Daycare ▢ Classes (swim/music) ▢ Photos
ZIP code: ______
3) The offer screen (70–110 words, one CTA)
Keep it human. Consent sits right under the button.
[Partner] helps with [need] in [area]—fast response, clear next step. Tell us where to reach you and we’ll line up [consult / trial / quote] that actually fits.
→ [Primary CTA]
By checking the box below, you agree to hear from [Partner] about this request. Opt out anytime.
4) Routing (no-code setup)
Form: Youform or Tally (branching logic).
Automation: Zapier/Make:
Trigger: New form submission.
Actions:
Create row in Airtable/Sheet (lead_id, email, name, zip, need, timing, partner_id, consent_text, timestamp, IP, sms_opt_in, utm).
Send to partner: email or webhook → HubSpot/Pipedrive/Calendly.
Tag subscriber in ESP (segment by need).
5) Pricing (start ranges)
Local services: $18–$40 per qualified lead
New-parent services: $15–$55 CPL
Licensed pros (dental/ortho/therapy): $25–$60 CPL
SMB B2B (funding/bookkeeping): $80–$250 per booked call (or $25–$60/qualified form fill)
Tune after the first 50–100 leads based on close-rate/LTV.
6) The 60-second math check (keep yourself honest)
For 100 new subscribers at $1.20 CAC = $120 cost.
If 40 opt in → your internal cost/lead = $120 / 40 = $3.00.
Sell those at $22 CPL → $880 revenue → $760 gross margin to reinvest.
Even at 25% opt-in and $18 CPL: 25 × $18 = $450 on $120 cost.
7) What not to do (avoids 80% of headaches)
Don’t show an “offer wall.” One offer wins; walls confuse.
Don’t use generic consent (“partners may contact you”). Name the brand.
Don’t pass sensitive data; only what the partner needs (email, ZIP, need, timing).
Don’t wait to route. Send in real time (speed-to-lead matters).
Don’t promise outcomes you can’t measure; pick CPL or CPL-Booked, not vibes.
8) 72-hour launch checklist
Day 1: Build the micro-form + 3 offer screens (local, parent, pro).
Day 2: Wire Zapier → Airtable + partner inbox; test payloads; create segments in ESP.
Day 3: Send 30 pilot emails (10 per category). Turn on light acquisition to the subscribe page. Ship your first weekly report.
That’s it. You don’t need a giant audience. You need a clean 20-second bridge between subscribe and specific help—and a price per outcome that both sides can live with.
Most important thing is to find that potential partner and the rest is golden.
Why this works
Peak intent window: People are most decisive right after subscribing.
One choice > many: A single, relevant offer converts; walls of logos don’t.
Consent-first trust: Name the partner. Store proof. Route fast.
🛠️ Want help?
Reply “FLOW” and I’ll send: the exact Youform/Tally setup, consent text, Zapier routes, and a pilot IO you can copy.
See you next send,
— Mo from GoLetter
Reply